Already a Subscriber? Log in
Get Instant Access to This Article
Subscribe to Mainebiz and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
- Critical Maine business news updated daily.
- Immediate access to all subscriber-only content on our website.
- Bi-weekly print or digital editions of our award-winning publication.
- Special bonus issues like the Mainebiz Book of Lists.
- Exclusive ticket prize draws for our in-person events.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article
Have you ever dined with a condiment connoisseur — someone who insists everything must have a generous squeeze of ketchup, mayo or mustard, along with extra salt and spices? Others wouldn't dream of leaving home without their favorite hot sauce or ranch. For these condiment lovers, flavor isn't just a preference — it's a way of life.
In a recent article for Bon Appétit magazine ("Is It Ever OK to BYO Seasonings to a Restaurant?"), Maggie Hennessy explores the spicy debate over whether bringing your own emergency flavorings to a restaurant is good dining etiquette.
Some chefs say a little extra seasoning isn't necessarily a culinary crime, including Chicago-based chef Cecil Rodriguez. He also admits to carrying his own tin of Jacobsen sea salt.
Other chefs interviewed for the story, such as Jonathan McDowell of Forth Hotel in Atlanta, recommend tasting the food first and asking about a restaurant's specialty house-made sauces before reaching into your purse or pocket.
While self-seasoning may be more noticeable at fine-dining establishments, the overall message is that personal taste matters, as long as customers respect the chef’s work and the dining experience.
Mainers weigh in
To get some fresh takes on the condiments conundrum, Friday Food Insider checked in with a handful of New Englanders who like to eat out.
"If you have to bring your own condiments or spices to a restaurant, then I don't expect that restaurant to be around very long," said Dustyn Bailey, founder of Bebop Collective. "No, I do not bring spices and condiments to a restaurant, but sometimes I do wish Valentina hot sauce would be at every Mexican restaurant, because, hot take, it's better than Chalula, in all its many forms."
At the other end of the spectrum, another restaurant goer admits to packing more unusual essentials.
"I had a second date coming up and was nervous, so the night before, I went to the Pilot House in Kennebunk with friends and got some free Jell-O shots," said Alexandra Martemucci, a New Hampshire resident who's originally from Maine.
"I had a couple left over, so I stuck them in the fridge and tossed two in my purse the day of the date," she said. "Completely forgot about them until they exploded and absolutely destroyed my bag."
It's not a typical seasoning mishap — and whether Jell-O shots technically qualify as a condiment is perhaps another topic of debate.
Jenna Caswell, an education coordinator in Bedford, N.H., likes to have a sweet treat on hand at all times. She regularly carries a jar of marshmallow fluff and a spoon, with Ritz crackers stashed in her car just in case.
"Fluff because it's delicious," said Caswell. "Why deny myself a sweet treat when I need it?"
Then there are the packet hoarders, stashing sugar, honey, hot sauce, mayo and mustard from the restaurant to take home. Others keep Lactaid handy for any dairy-filled indulgences.
Reader feedback
Have you ever brought condiments to a restaurant or know someone who does? The Mainebiz Food Insider is hungry to hear from Maine's condiment connoisseurs. Contact Alexis Wells at awells@mainebiz.biz.