Already a Subscriber? Log in
Get Instant Access to This Article
Subscribe to Mainebiz and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
- Critical Maine business news updated daily.
- Immediate access to all subscriber-only content on our website.
- Bi-weekly print or digital editions of our award-winning publication.
- Special bonus issues like the Mainebiz Book of Lists.
- Exclusive ticket prize draws for our in-person events.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article
Cashiers and fast-food workers are more at risk of losing their jobs to AI, while health care workers and teachers may be less affected because their work is harder to automate, according to a report by the Augusta-based Maine Center for Economic Policy.
Drawing on lessons from past technological advances, the study notes that computers and the internet widened the income gap between college-educated workers and those without college degrees. While the former saw their wages rise, the latter experienced declining wages as technology replaced some of the tasks they had previously performed.
While AI could further widen these gaps, early evidence suggests that the technology could replace tasks performed by college-educated workers or help them do their jobs more efficiently without necessarily increasing their pay, the report finds.
It warns that unchecked AI could deepen income inequality and recommends policy solutions ranging from requiring employers to disclose AI-related layoffs to expanding access to affordable higher education and retraining for displaced and at-risk workers.
James Myall, a senior economic policy analyst who wrote the 33-page report for the nonpartisan research and policy organization, told Mainebiz that he was most surprised by the amount of evidence suggesting there is reason to be cautious or skeptical about the extent of AI disruption.
“Looking back at the history of prior automation efforts helped me understand how ‘hit or miss’ this can be, and how much people value human interaction even when it's not the most economically efficient," he told Mainebiz.
The report includes links to first-person accounts from Mainers across different professions. One participant, a journalist named Margaret working remotely, lamented that AI is being used to produce shorter news stories for her news outlet that were previously written by reporters, often with errors.
'Babysitting robots'
Myall said he was struck by how far AI adoption has gone in some workplaces.
“Some of our storytellers described their work as essentially babysitting robots or watching their jobs disappear,” he said. “It was a good example of how the data doesn't always capture these individual impacts and how even if someone isn't laid off, having their job change dramatically can be really demoralizing for them.”
He also emphasized that while AI could make businesses in Maine more profitable, those gains will not automatically lead to the creation or retention of good-paying jobs.
“State lawmakers need to adopt policies that ensure any AI productivity gains are shared with workers if we want Mainers to have jobs that are sustainable for workers and the economy,” he said. “Ultimately, that's the way we attract and retain talent.”
Policy guardrails
From the list of recommended policy measures, Myall said he believes recommendations to protect workers from the worst effects of AI could be adopted relatively easily.
“Other states have already passed laws to ban algorithmic wage setting and to put guardrails on how AI is used in hiring,” he noted. “Ensuring that our tax code doesn't incentivize adoption of AI over hiring people is also a relatively straightforward fix that will help.”