Belfast council wants state to get moving on Nordic Aquafarms application
COURTESY / NORDIC AQUAFARMS INC.
An interior view of Nordic Aquafarms’ land-based aquaculture facility in Frederikstad, Norway. The Belfast City Council is asking the state Board of Environmental Protection to issue its findings on the proposal by May 7.
The Belfast City Council is asking a state board to get on with its review of a land-based salmon farm proposal by videoconference, rather than wait until it can meet in person.
The Maine Department of Environmental Protection’s Board of Environmental Protection was tentatively scheduled to hold its final deliberations and issue findings May 7 on an application by Nordic Aquafarms to develop a land-based salmon aquaculture facility. It would be sited on a 56-acre parcel along the northwesterly side of U.S. Route 1, near the lower reservoir of the Little River.
But at its April 21 meeting, held by videoconference, the council learned that the board was considering waiting until it could meet in person.
Council members said they were concerned about a delay in the board’s deliberations because the pandemic made it impossible to predict when the board might be able to safely convene. Nordic’s application has been winding its way through the permit process for over two years.
The council agreed to send a letter to the board that expresses the city’s gratitude for the board’s help in reviewing the application, and indicates that the board’s input is essential to city planning board’s upcoming review of the application. The letter was also to ask the board to release its findings as originally scheduled on May 7.
“They have a lot of technical expertise that we don’t have,” Councilor Mike Hurley said. “We’ll either rely on their expertise or we‘ve got to hire experts.”
“We have seen delay after delay after delay,” said Councilor Neal Harkness. “We’re hoping to see this move forward. We’re going to be coming out of this virus situation in a depression in this country. The possibility that we could get economic development moving sooner rather than later — that’s imperative.”
“Two-and-a-half years is enough time for many things — that includes a proposed fish farm,” said Mayor Eric Sanders. The operation, he added, could be an “economic lever that would help the city of Belfast, now and in the next 10, 20, 30 years.”
The city planning board's review of Nordic’s application will resume in May, Wayne Marshall, director of code and planning, told the council. He noted that the Board of Environmental Protection’s input would be useful for the planning board as it considers topics related to the application such as natural resource protection, wetland impact and discharge into the bay.
After hearings held in March, the Maine Department of Marine Resources determined that dredging and construction of intake and discharge pipes, related to Nordic’s project, were feasible from the standpoint of fishing operations, contingent on certain recommendations to minimize impacts.
The department sent its comments in a memorandum dated April 7 to the Maine Department of Environmental Protection’s Bureau of Land and Water Quality Control.
The department said that local fishermen and a shellfish aquaculture operator were concerned about potential impacts pertaining to construction activities and the haul route of the dredging barge, about discharge from the pipes, and about potential reduction in landings due to physical and biochemical changes of the marine environment.
The department recommended the use of a closed bucket dredge and turbidity curtains around the barge and excavation site. It encouraged marking the location of the pipelines for navigational safety. And it asked Nordic to have its construction contractor communicate its construction plans with the department and with the local lobster zone council.
In a decision dated April 3, the Board of Environmental Protection denied a request by opponents of the project to reopen the proceedings or dismiss Nordic’s application.
The permitting process has affected Nordic’s original timeline. In 2018, Nordic projected that, pending approvals, initial construction could begin in the summer of 2019.
Nordic proposes to develop the project in two phases over five or more years. Total production capacity at build-out is estimated to be 72.7 million pounds of salmon per year.
Most Recent
Most Recent
It's not about fish it is about who owns our drinking water
The Belfast City Council may want the BEP to act swiftly to conclude permit deliberations on the Nordic Aquafarms application, but this article omits all of the reasons that the process has been dragging on for a year and a half. To begin with, Nordic has never shown sufficient Title, Right , and Interest in the intertidal land over which it would like to place its pipes, and in fact there are Slander of Title actions pending in both the State and Federal Courts. Add to that Nordic's revelation at the March Division of Marine Resources Public Meeting that it plans on blasting, dredging, hauling, and dewatering hundreds of bargeloads of potentially mercury-contaminated ocean bottom, without ever obtaining a dredge permit or doing adequate mercury testing along the proposed pipe route. Add to that new plans brought forward at the time of the BEP Hearings that triggered air quality emissions concerns and the requirement for additional evidence; the necessity to excavate and remove millions of cubic yards of unsuitable soil from the 44 acre building site up to a depth of 20 feet ; the insufficiency of well water on the site requiring the use of ground water and additional water from the City's public drinking supply; the revelations of the warmer temperature, lower salinity, and slow dispersal of the 7.7 million gallons/day discharge plume into Penobscot Bay. The list is too long to relay it all.
Our thanks to the BEP for taking the time necessary to thoroughly examine the legitimate scientific and environmental concerns that have arisen over the time period that this permit has been studied. These are indeed catastrophic times, but it is shortsighted to fall prey to disaster capitalism.
5 Comments