Please do not leave this page until complete. This can take a few moments.
Maine’s Business and Consumer Court handed a pre-Labor Day victory to workers at FairPoint Communications Inc. (NASDAQ: FRP) when it canceled a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Commission that denied unemployment benefits to the striking employees during the 2014-15 labor dispute and sent the case back to the commission for further review.
In its Aug. 26 decision, the court rejected the commission’s mandate that in order to obtain benefits, the employees had to prove that the Charlotte, N.C.-based FairPoint had maintained substantially normal operations during a four-month labor dispute. The court ruled that the commission erred when it placed the burden of proof on employees, rather than FairPoint, to show that there had not been a stoppage of work.
The business court’s decision was the first time that the Maine courts have addressed who has the burden of proof in labor disputes, according to a written statement from attorneys Jeffrey Neil Young and Roberta de Araujo of the Augusta law firm Johnson, Webbert & Young, who represented the FairPoint employees. Young and de Araujo said the business court’s decision means that the case will be returned to the Unemployment Insurance Commission for reconsideration of its decision.
“FairPoint must now prove that there was a substantial curtailment of work for each and every week of the strike,” Young said in a written statement. “Workers do not strike often, and usually only strike as a last resort in the face of extreme employer conduct. The FairPoint strikers will be able, at least for the near future, to keep the unemployment benefits they received pursuant to a decision of a Department of Labor hearing officer, who found (unlike the commission) that no substantial curtailment had occurred. And, it should be easier in the future for employees involved in a labor dispute to receive unemployment benefits, particularly where, as here, the employer chooses to hire strike replacements.”
FairPoint told Mainebiz in a written response to questions about the decision that it disagrees with the court’s ruling and will reiterate in the next stage of the process its position that the strikers are not entitled to unemployment benefits.
“We continue to fundamentally believe that employees who voluntarily leave their job should not be entitled to unemployment benefits,” Angelynne Beaudry, FairPoint’s director of corporate communications, said in the written statement. “This decision not only potentially impacts FairPoint, but also any other business currently operating in or considering coming to Maine, and we intend to work with the commission to support our position.”
In February 2015, FairPoint ratified the new contract with two unions that had been striking for months, a move that allowed 1,800 members across Maine and two other states to return to work. The contract with the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers and the Communications Workers of America included a cheaper, union-administered health plan and helped protect jobs from outsourcing, Peter McLaughlin, a spokesman for Maine's IBEW chapter, said at the time of the contract’s ratification.
Editor's note: The first paragraph of this story has been revised to provide a more precise legal description of the Maine Business and Consumer Court's Aug. 26 decision.
Read more
FairPoint eyes telecom deregulation as a path to move forward
Regulators investigate FairPoint’s 2015 quality performance
Service changes to FairPoint landlines raising concerns
FairPoint acquires Falmouth communications company
FairPoint faces $500K PUC fine
High usage leads to FairPoint’s ‘cost recovery’ fee
The Giving Guide helps nonprofits have the opportunity to showcase and differentiate their organizations so that businesses better understand how they can contribute to a nonprofit’s mission and work.
Learn MoreWork for ME is a workforce development tool to help Maine’s employers target Maine’s emerging workforce. Work for ME highlights each industry, its impact on Maine’s economy, the jobs available to entry-level workers, the training and education needed to get a career started.
Learn MoreFew people are adequately prepared for all the tasks involved in planning and providing care for aging family members. SeniorSmart provides an essential road map for navigating the process. This resource guide explores the myriad of care options and offers essential information on topics ranging from self-care to legal and financial preparedness.
Learn moreThe Giving Guide helps nonprofits have the opportunity to showcase and differentiate their organizations so that businesses better understand how they can contribute to a nonprofit’s mission and work.
Work for ME is a workforce development tool to help Maine’s employers target Maine’s emerging workforce. Work for ME highlights each industry, its impact on Maine’s economy, the jobs available to entry-level workers, the training and education needed to get a career started.
Few people are adequately prepared for all the tasks involved in planning and providing care for aging family members. SeniorSmart provides an essential road map for navigating the process. This resource guide explores the myriad of care options and offers essential information on topics ranging from self-care to legal and financial preparedness.
In order to use this feature, we need some information from you. You can also login or register for a free account.
By clicking submit you are agreeing to our cookie usage and Privacy Policy
Already have an account? Login
Already have an account? Login
Want to create an account? Register
In order to use this feature, we need some information from you. You can also login or register for a free account.
By clicking submit you are agreeing to our cookie usage and Privacy Policy
Already have an account? Login
Already have an account? Login
Want to create an account? Register
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Our privacy policy
To ensure the best experience on our website, articles cannot be read without allowing cookies. Please allow cookies to continue reading. Our privacy policy
Comments